The Story of Amazon & The Destruction of a career

12/23/2021

12.25.21
Two edits were made for clarity.
1. I had 700 reviews and ratings, not reviews only. I apologize for not realize you could rate without reviewing on Amazon until it was brought to my attention.
2. updated verbiage on the review notice to avoid semantical conversations or confusion based on policy.
3. A link to part 2 that includes more of the process and my fight.

The last 30ish hours have been very hard for me. Somehow, I offended Amazon's KDP system and my entire career has been taken down. This blog is my attempt to share only the facts, while leaving out any opinions and emotions. At present, 43 books have been unpublished, over $300 in advertising dollars on a new release from 12.20.21 are wasted, and over 700 reviews & ratings are now gone. All of this occurred just 24 hours after my latest release, which was the first release I've had since last Christmas, due to fighting a mystery illness and COVID parenting a toddler - writing took a backseat.

Please consider sharing this blog on your social media. I want to effect change within Amazon more than I want my career back. If enough of us make noise, it's possible this can all be changed.

This post might be lengthy, but I promise, It's not extraneous information.

To set the stage about me for what it might be worth, I am a 2x USA Today Bestselling Author. I began publishing through the fantastic confidence of CHBB Publishing in summer of 2015 before branching out to self publish in summer of 2017. Since 2015, over 54 novels were written and published. Many were shorts in anthologies. Some of those shorts were republished when the anthologies ended and rights returned, but not all. While my review count was a modest total of just over 700, they were still reviews.

I write across the bulk of romance subgenres, with a focus on paranormal romance, steampunk romance and Christmas romance. My works are not all under 18 friendly, but some were.

On Monday, December 19, 2021 I uploaded a listing for preorder through Kindle Direct Publishing (to be referred to as KDP in future references). The listing included a cover, my name, the book name, and a blurb. There were no files attached and the release date was set for December 15, 2022. it was book 5 in my Modern Christmas Fairy Tale series.

Blurb: Love at first sight isn't real, but Xander couldn’t deny his attraction to the stunning woman he met at the Christmas market. Even if she was nobility from Europe and more than a little out of his league. Being a homeless, ex-military man wouldn’t win him any favors. Xander wanted to be more than he was, to change his stars.

Lily ran from a list of suitors a mile long only to trip and fall into a man’s arms. She let him think she was merely a tourist, and explored his city as he saw it. She didn’t expect to find herself attracted to him, or to ever see him again.

When Xander saves the life of an antique shop owner, the man happens to see a rusty lamp Xander held onto from his days overseas. The owner offers Xander a handsome seller's fee, and Xander takes it, knowing with that amount of money, he would change his world. All that was left to do was find Lily and help her choose him over the other men fighting for her attention.

One magic lamp. One displaced army vet and one royal princess are thrown together for a Christmas adventure.

Shortly after, I received a message that I had violated copyright with my content and that my preorder was locked.

After 5 hours of searching their platform I found nothing with the same title or similar cover. I did however, of course, find my own series and similar covers. An email exchange occurred during this time and it was reinstated. I did inquire as to what caused the issue, but was never responded to.

Christmas and the Lamp went live shortly after.

Wednesday morning, I submitted a preorder for my next book, The Race, and it too, was quickly published live.

I checked my email midmorning and found the following email.

I went to check KDP even after verifying the email address was legitimate. The random ruling was.

As I am human, my next course of action included breaking down. I have been a published author - indie house, small presses, and self - for just over 6 years. I have been included in or solo'd in 54 novels + the two preorders.

Per the email, my books were gone. My reviews were gone. My royalties would not be paid - yes, you read that correctly, Amazon was going to keep money I made on all my BACKLIST titles because the preorder raised a flag. I also cannot create another KDP account to begin again (which is fair if I'd done what I was accused of doing or anything else).

I took to social media for help, because my account was blocked so I couldn't "contact us" beyond a form fill and I wasn't content with that. To see the Facebook post, click here.

The next 5-7 hours (5 continuously and then another 2 here and there after) were spend trying to get ahold of someone to make a decision.

The steps I took (condensed but assume each step occured anywhere from 5-12 times):

replied to the original email
chat with KDP
new email cases with KDP
searched for numbers to call with no luck
emailed [email protected]
phone calls with amazon customer service
youtube video
searched social groups for help/steps

What I learned/encountered:

KDP can terminate your account at any time for any reason, thus removing the ability to involve a lawyer because they owe you nothing and can do whatever they want.
KDP US has ZERO ways to contact a live on the phone person. I tried calling customer service, I tried asking chat reps. I tried so long I ended up with 13 cases open for me.
This is a grueling process and most are successful after being wrongfully terminated, but a great deal are not.
Never upload via Amazon. The ability to sell ads and on KDP is not worth this as they cannot go after you on the third party uploads.

I went to bed heartbroken, and clingy to a small shred of hope.
The first thing I did this morning was check my email. Nothing. I held hope that it meant they were taking it very seriously.

Then the emails began. They continued to uphold that there was something misleading and dangerous to sellers about a listing with nothing more than a title or blurb that sincerely do match. At the time of writing this, I'm up to 11 "rejections".

Not one person has responded to my request to learn what is so misleading that they can terminate my career. Not one person has even offered to call. I want this process changed, and I'll get into that in a minute, but for now, please enjoy a series of screenshots from people telling me that the work I posted at the beginning of the blog is misleading and dangerous.

My goal is to continue to message until I get a response. I do wish to get a lawyer involved for specifics, but since they can terminate anyone for any reason at any time, it's unlikely to help.

There needs to be a change. Amazon cannot keep treating clients and customers this way - we are both because we also buy our paperbacks as well as countless other products from them.

How this process should go:

A warning email with explicit information, not just a title and open for interpretation comments
A case worker from KDP assigned to an author when this occurs.
Phone calls.
Highlighted proof
Accounts being frozen and not terminated until proven guilty.

A change this huge is not likely to happen no matter how loud the voices get, but I ask you, let's join together and make our voices heard so the next set of authors are treated fairly.

Please consider sharing this blog on your social media to help raise awareness of how dangerous it is. My account was terminated, but all royalties, not just on the offending book, were taken from me.

What comes next for Lexi Ostrow?

It will take some time, but while I continue to fight Amazon, I hope to republish my work on wide networks, as I've dreamed of being an author since I was 7.

I do have another, selfish, request. If you have the time, and would like to help, I'm going to need reviews to get my work shared and trusted once again. If you love to read and wouldn't mind honest reviews when the time comes, please fill out this form to receive communications on how to receive titles and necessary verbiage for posted reviews.

Please fill out this form to be contacted when I'm fortunate enough to take my career back, even if it's never on Amazon which would be upsetting for sure.

If you are an author who has been through - whether you were reinstated or not - I'd love to hear from you. Comment on this blog post or shoot me an email. Let's work together to stop Amazon from pulling this on other authors.

Thank you for your time in reading this.

For more updates please consider reading part 2 as my fight with Amazon has only just begun.

38 Comments

Heidi Schmidt

12/23/2021 05:16:03 pm

Your link above says "free copies in exchange for review" which is great, but I really, really hope your fans, people who have already read your work, will step up and post reviews again! 700 is a lot, and I am so sorry you are going through this, what a nightmare!!! I love your conflict resolution ideas, I think it would streamline the Amazon process. Good luck to you, hopefully Amazon will get you reinstated quickly!!

Lexi Ostrow

12/24/2021 09:09:43 am

Thank you for the support! I would love to get as many back as possible, but realistically after 6 years and many non blogger reviews, it’s not possible so I’ve got to begin to grow them again :)

Matthew W Quinn

12/24/2021 06:20:03 am

In case this doesn't work out, have you considered republishing all of them via Draft2Digital? Not only will this get the books onto sites like Barnes and Noble, Kobo, etc. but it's also a back-door back onto Amazon.

If you still have the ASIN numbers for all your books, it might even be possible to contact Amazon to get the reviews restored. That's what I've done with indie books bought up by small presses and a book by a small press I got the rights back to and republished.

Also, if you're blocked by KDP and can't contact them, have you tried Amazon Author Central as a way of contacting them? AAC might be the ones to contact to get the reviews back, although I'm not sure.

12/24/2021 09:10:22 am

Hi! Thanks for commenting. Author Central was technically disbanded in 2020. However, I did not think to try logging into the new portal, thank you for the idea! Unfortunately, my account is dead there as well.

Paul S. Forrester

1/3/2022 06:40:43 am

Smashwords is definitely worth a try. Very active and treat their authors well - they also publish to B&N and lots of other well known retailers.

I've no link to them other than a small time scribbler that sells via them.

S. J. Pajonas link

12/24/2021 08:09:47 pm

If you are banned from Sam’s I you cannot use D2D as a back door to get back on there. D2D won’t allow it and neither will Amazon. Sorry. I’ve seen this happen to other people.

12/24/2021 08:15:40 pm

https://www.draft2digital.com/faq/

It says that in their FAQs, but how would they actually make that happen? Would Amazon's e-bookstore recognize the author's name or book content coming in from D2D as something they banned earlier?

12/25/2021 04:00:43 pm

Technically, I have been banned, not my books - so I have been given the consent that it is tryable. Example: I could be published via a publisher for all my old titles and they would go through.

There might be small issues with copyright proof, but the system only flagged me, not my work ironically.

That said, I'm not going to put up my work on Amazon again for old titles for quite some time - like 6 months or more - so if I experience an issue, I'll for sure share how the process went!

Ashton

12/24/2021 06:24:48 am

Offering free copies or offering yo pay gorgeous reviews is a violation of KDPs terms of service. That's why you were rejected because you're offering free stuff in exchange for reviews. It makes the reviews and thus the book and your number of followers misleading. THAT is why you were banned and that is 100% why you won't get your account back if you continue to make offers like this and someone reports any of your reviews as being paid for

12/24/2021 09:08:59 am

I apologize that you are confused. Offering free copies of works in exchange for honest reviews is 100% in policy AND has nothing to do with misleading content.

All publishers utilize review copies and often times review arcs. Check out sites like NetGalley and see all the trad houses using it.

The reviewer is the one who needs to make a statement that the book was gifted in exchange for an honest review.

I encourage you to do some research on your own before attacking someone. Additionally, if you’re an author, knowing their review policies is very important.

IndiePubGirl

12/24/2021 07:54:46 pm

No, the commenter above is correct though their wording was harsh. It is technically against Amazon policies to offer a free book/ebook in exchange for a review. You can give a free book with no strings attached and hope someone reviews, but to give it in exchange for a review is a violation of Amazon policy. But you are right, that has nothing to do with "misleading" content. I am so sorry you're going through this, but I'd be very careful going forward about the language you use around ARCs.

12/25/2021 04:03:37 pm

Books are allowed to be given for free - there is nothing in their terms and services against this so long as it is stated in the review that it is how the novel was received. Additionally, I am not forcing people to review or exchanging anything in favor of a false or positive review. It might be considered frowned upon, but it is not against their terms - I can do another blog on this at a later time and share my screenshots, but right now this is not my main concern. I thank you for being polite in looking out for me! We need to do this for each other more :)

When getting new copies to readers, they will be free to reader, but not free as I will gift them from sites. I will make an update note and an update to the verbiage to reflect the correct procedure.

Charity Rowell

12/31/2021 10:26:15 am

I know you mentioned that you were going to address the comments regarding offering free books to help recoup the number of reviews in the future, so I thought I'd give you the link to the guidelines since I have it handy: https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=201929730

The sub-section that people are looking for is "Promotions And Commercial Solicitation," and Amazon directly discusses it in the last paragraph of the section immediately before the sub-section "Sexual Content." It gives explicit consent for the practice of offering free books.

mir

3/23/2022 10:29:25 am

Quoting directly from Zon:
Book authors and publishers may continue to provide free or discounted copies of their books to readers, as long as the author or publisher does not require a review in exchange or attempt to influence the review.

This seems to say an author cannot ask even for an honest review, which is crazy, since even standard/large publishers send out ARCs for review (free books for honest reviews).

Amazon needs to reword this, cause it seems to say you can give out books, but say NOTHING about reviews, honest or otherwise.

I pretty much stopped accepting ARCs back when I was a top 200 reviewer. I didn't like putting that "I got this book free for review" thing, which I figured made it look suspect. I only review books I buy (and rarely these days as I really fear stepping on the Zon's big toes. )

I hope Amazon looks into the unfairness of how they treat authors (in cases like yours and others I've heard of where finding out what the violation is clearly and getting things resolved can be really difficult and costly in terms of lost reviews, lost time, lost royalties, etc.)

12/24/2021 06:26:40 am

Oops. Didn't see that you hoped to republish wide *while* the fight with Amazon was ongoing. In that case, D2D might be a good way to get everything on multiple platforms *fast.*

Golden Angel

12/24/2021 07:15:28 am

I'm so sorry you're going through this! I didn't get my account shut down, but I did have something similar a few years ago when I tried to submit a book under my other penname - Dark Angel. I'd had that pen name for years, but all of the sudden I got an email saying they couldn't publish my book because it would cause a confusing customer experience since either my title or author name was too close to someone else's.

Went to check Amazon and lo and behold, someone else had started publishing as Dark Angel. Now, granted, it was kind of my 'throwaway' name where I shoved anything that didn't fit my Golden Angel penname, which meant I hadnt released anything in about a year, but I was FURIOUS since I'd had that pen name for years, but NOW suddenly it ws confusing that I was using it when they'd let someone ELSE start publishing with it? Why didn't THEY get the email that they were going to cause a confusing customer experience?

Not their fault at all, totally Amazon's.

After a month of back and forth emails, opening up tickets, and getting the same form email over and over again, I finally lost my temper and took to social media. Detailed the whole thing on Facebook and Twitter, tagged them in every tweet on the Twitter thread - not just KDP, but every one of their accounts that I could find including Amazon's customer service and Amazon itself.

Within 2 minutes I had a tweet back saying "I'm so sorry, but we can't help with this you need to contact _______" and I responded "Yes, if you read this whole tweet thread, you'll see that I've been talking to them for a month and they keep saying the same thing, even though I had the pen name first."

I didn't get another tweet, I didn't get another email, but the next morning I did get an email saying that my book had been published to the Kindle store. I ended up changing that pen name anyway, since I didn't want the exact same pen name as someone else, but yeah. It was a lesson to me that they really don't care until you make a big public stink.

So good luck! <3

12/24/2021 09:12:05 am

I am so sorry to hear the randomness of the situation but so grateful it worked out!

I plan to continue to fight via emails as best as I can as well as social. At this point, I’m hoping to learn how people succeeded, who didn’t, and how we can make Amazon change this process. Not even their policy, but just how the process goes down.

RJ Castiglione link

12/24/2021 09:43:01 am

I had something similar happen way back when. I was temporarily shut down because they claimed I was violating KDP Select marketing practices.

They canceled over a thousand dollars in royalties on a new release.

Ultimately, I was able to get on the phone and requested I be connected to the KDP Support team.

The outcome was that I removed all my books from Kindle Unlimited. I proceeded to launch wide, including selling from my own website (where I give away free copies).

In any case, try that. Specifically ask to speak to someone on the KDP Support team. They work with you rather than just reading off a script.

Lee Gabel link

12/24/2021 02:57:08 pm

I am so sorry to hear of your troubles. Perhaps the issue here is that you set up a preorder without any ebook files, even though the publish date was a year away.

It's ridiculous that Amazon won't tell you what the issue is.

I hope you get things resolved.

12/24/2021 08:41:55 pm

Thanks for your comment! Amazon does allow for you to upload with a file up to 3 days prior to release. I know it’s newer but I can’t find update release info without my account, apologies!

It’s important to note not all retailers are like that though!

Malcolm Barber

12/24/2021 03:01:31 pm

I read a number of genres and always review what I read.?Id be happy to add any arcs to my reading list in the future.

12/24/2021 03:42:03 pm

You aren't alone in this battle. You really should contact the Author's Guild. They have been helping Indies as well as trad. published authors and they have been filing suits against Amazon for this sort of thing.

12/24/2021 07:05:13 pm

Oh that's a good idea. There's also the Alliance of Independent Authors.

Kasey

12/24/2021 08:00:06 pm

So an idea as you move forward is to calculate how much money your sales have made Amazon over the years. I'll be following, good luck.

12/24/2021 08:40:22 pm

Unfortunately I make them nothing when you compare me to a traditionally published author and a decent handful of indie authors.

Tamara

12/25/2021 11:58:33 am

I'm so sorry to hear this happened to you. It goes to show how easy it is to misstep and how high the stakes can be. I'd suggest you keep trying after Christmas. I know people who have got their accounts back before, but not all do.

If you had your books in Kindle Unlimited, I'd be cautious about listing them up elsewhere before your terms expire, despite the fact they've closed your account. You don't want to be in breach of terms if you get it back. However, I know you need to have your books up somewhere in order to have money coming in from them.

I have to wonder if they were harsher because of the connection to a story that Disney turned into a movie. I've heard that Disney are notorious about going after anything that they feel violates their IP. It's possible Amazon might have treated it more cautiously because of that. Do you remember what your keywords were now? It's possible that connecting Aladdin to a more adult story might've figured into their reaction too (despite the fact Aladdin is a folk tale).

They could be overcautious when it comes to anything Disney, but it's hard to say for sure. Don't give up. You'll get past this no matter what happens with your Amazon account and there are other places to publish.

Lexi Ostrow link

12/25/2021 03:58:37 pm

Hi, thank you for your comment.

I did check into this - as long as my account is terminated, all contracts are as well. If, in the small chance they change their mind which is not likely after everything I've been through, all my books automatically are removed from KDP select and are not published until I republish them. Getting the account back just gets my account back.

The connection to Disney should not be a problem or I - and hundreds of others - would have gone down awhile ago. This is because these main stories are open source and not protected by a copyright at this time due to the origin/date of their creation. This story will focus on the premise of a homeless person using a lamp to get rich and find his love and has no ties back to disney at all but the original work.

Thanks for the thought! I truly appreciate how people are trying to help - ultimately, the issue is I need to speak to someone because I am certain once I can, this can be sorted.

alexis ostrow

12/27/2021 09:29:08 pm

Hi! Thanks for commenting!

This story is actually not connected to Disney in any way but rather Arabian Nights - which is public domain. Thankfully, my error is not copyright or I would assume they messed up and dropped the ball thinking it was Disney as well! I know Disney is a beast as I've done a few of their fairy tales earlier in the series and was so cautious!

Colleen

12/27/2021 07:53:40 am

So I have read some of your books and just checked they are still available for purchase. So this means they are able to continue to make money off of your work? Is that not in fact stealing?

12/27/2021 09:27:54 pm

Hi Colleen!
Thanks for commenting.

Yes, it has been brought to my attention that my entire catalog has been back about 36 hours without any change to my account. I am able to "sell" but there is no tracking or royalty payment option tied to my account - meaning Amazon is taking all the money. I do plan on doing an update about this, but was trying to get all information before posting.

Thank you so much for looking out for me during all this mess!

Noname

12/27/2021 03:52:59 pm

You have bestselling author on your cover. (Can't use it in keywords either)

https://kdp.amazon.com/en_US/help/topic/G201097560

KPD/Amazon only want that on the book or books that made it on that list. Sometimes they don't even want it then or want proof.

https://www.amarketingexpert.com/2017/02/07/kdp-amazon-bestseller-news/

Yes, other authors have it, traditionally published can do as they please, but it clearly says in their guidelines that they don't want it on there. When you put it on your preorder it got flagged, they saw they over looked it and took harsh action.

12/27/2021 09:26:19 pm

Thanks for your comment!

This error message does not fit with the error I have received. My error dealt with misleading content. Additionally, this refers to not placing it in the title or keywords, which are metadata coded fields and keywords weren't even used during the preorder. My error deals with the cover requirements lower. The issue is likely linked to the fact that they assigned the same AISN number to Christmas and the Hero & Christmas and the Lamp. That is being investigated currently, but it is the likely cause of the problem. I 100% respect Amazon for wanting proof of "rank titles" and actually did have to submit myself when I earned the honor in 2017.

Thanks again though because this information could help someone else!

Sue link

12/30/2021 02:14:55 pm

I checked my KDP account this morning, went out to shovel snow and came back in to find my account, which housed 3 separate pen names for 3 separate genres had been closed. No trace of me anywhere on Amazon.

I have no email telling me what my transgression was and the 4 CSRs I've spoken to so far can't see anything, or can't access my account.

I have only been publishing again since July, so my catalogue isn't huge, but still, a warning and a chance to fix any issues would have been nice.

Elisabeth

1/4/2022 10:47:52 am

What if you had written: "Inspired by the story of Aladdin and the lamp"
Not everyone knows the story is a classic. They might have thought they bought a book with the story of Aladdin.

Craig Tuch link

1/7/2022 10:51:14 am

Hi Lexi - thanks for posting about your experience, it's so important for authors to know what's going on. This issue affected a number of authors recently, and really stresses the point that Amazon needs a proper appeals process that can be used for cases like this - ideally before it gets to the account termination stage.

FYI, I wanted to let you know that I wrote a lengthy blog about this and referenced these articles in the hopes of getting more attention to the issue. It's part 1 of 2 as it got a bit long, but you can read it here if you're interested: https://www.hiddengemsbooks.com/amazon-appeals-process-overdue-p1/

Thanks!

nlowhim link

3/8/2022 02:12:28 pm

Thank you for sharing this and I truly hope all this gets resolved. I actually had a similar issue at the start of February where Amazon deleted all my audiobooks without warning. First they claimed that it was a copyright issue. Then an email claimed it was something else. I responded to that email and haven't heard a thing from them. Some of these books had been up for close to 9 years. So it was quite the surprise. I'm still trying to hear back from them. Apparently this happens all the time. All the best to you.

Salty vixen link

3/24/2023 12:22:31 pm

feb.2023 - my account along with thousands for ‘ misleading services’ 5 years on KDp and poof gone! I am still appealing- no idea what happened. I always followed kdp tos- only thing I can think is piracy. But still- why us authors suffer? They need a better system instead of instantly terminating accounts.

Rotemburg

5/8/2024 03:11:05 am

I had the same issue on the 15th April, 2024. Out of the blue I got a termination mail on the claims that I run multiple accounts which is absolutely false. I have almost $3,000 royalty forfeited, I appealed and at a point asked that the mails or accounts amazon claims were linked to me be given to me and poof another mail was immediately sent to me, terminating the account afresh on the 25th April, 2024 claiming I violated content guidelines.